---
title: 'Progressive Christianity?'
type: text
hasMedia: true
requiresPurchase: false
authors:
- 'Jonathan Master'
date: 2026-11-17
collection: 'Articles'
subcollection: '2026'
topics:
- 'Social Issues'
- 'Christian Life'
- 'Character and Conduct of Life'
scriptures:
- '1 Corinthians 15'
- '1 Thessalonians 5'
url: https://confessional.org/articles/2026/progressive-christianity
---

# Progressive Christianity?

Drawing on Lyman Atwater, Dr. Master argues that true Christian progress requires steadfast commitment to the core truths of the faith, propelling deeper application of these doctrines and broader advancement of the gospel.

We live in an age that is obsessed with progress. Politicians and business leaders call for it. Even within the church, we hear that certain doctrines of the past need to be downplayed or amended to suit the next generation. The assumption behind all this is simple, and it is wrong: if something is new, it is better; if something is old, it holds us back.

But societies can move very quickly and still move in the wrong direction. Today, it seems as if every inherited belief is under suspicion. Every old institution needs to be torn down. Moral convictions which were once taken for granted are now regarded with disdain. It seems that all someone needs to say is that an idea is “old” or “from the past” and it will be regarded as outmoded and in need of change. Our desire for so-called progress becomes restless and relentless: always changing, always rebuilding, but never clear about where things are headed.

This is not a new problem. In 1852, the theologian Lyman Atwater, a pastor and vice president of Princeton Seminary, saw that the word *progress* was being used to justify almost every kind of change. Atwater was not opposed to progress. He believed Christians ought to pursue it. But he insisted on distinguishing real progress from false progress, and he warned against "that fickleness which mistakes mere change for improvement" (Atwater,  p. 17).

### Two Impulses

Behind these differing views of change, Atwater saw two fundamentally opposed impulses. The conservative impulse seeks to preserve the treasures of truth already gained and to use them as capital for still larger discoveries (19–20). The radical impulse, by contrast, is not content merely "to lop off diseased branches," but, to get rid of them, would "uproot and destroy the tree itself" (20). Radicals claim to want progress, but they only know how to tear down. They are not builders, only destroyers.

### Stability Makes Progress Possible

But, as Atwater recognized, real progress in the biblical sense requires something stable. A man cannot step forward without firm ground beneath his feet. This applies to the church and society as well.

We see this in God himself and his immutable nature. He never changes. In the Christian life, Scripture repeatedly connects growth in grace with steadfastness. The martyrs and reformers who did most to advance the cause of Christ were marked not by a restless desire to tear down, but by firm commitment to the truth and persistent faithfulness to it (21). They rooted their insights in unchanging Scripture and the clear testimony of the best of the past. This is what the Bible commands. The apostle Paul describes the Christian as "steadfast, immovable, always abounding in the work of the Lord," and he commands us to "hold fast that which is good" (1 Cor. 15:58; 1 Thess. 5:21; Atwater, 22).

But Atwater also saw the other side. Just as stability is essential for progress, biblical progress is necessary for healthy stability. Without growth, even sound doctrine can become a "dead orthodoxy": truths confessed with the lips, but with no power behind them. The church rightly progresses not by moving beyond biblical truth, but by understanding it more deeply, applying it more faithfully, and spreading it more widely (24–25).

Atwater was specific about what belongs to that stable foundation: that God is one being in three persons, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost; that mankind is in a state of sin and condemnation from which no man can deliver himself; that the Son of God became man, two distinct natures in one person forever; that Christ suffered and died in the place of sinners, rose, ascended, and will judge the world; that the Holy Spirit breaks the power of sin and transforms God's people; that salvation is freely offered and received by faith; that faith, repentance, and holy living are necessary to salvation; and that the saved will receive the resurrection of the body and everlasting life (27). These are the truths of the historic faith, and to deny such fundamental doctrines is to reject Christianity itself (27–28). Because the Holy Spirit confirms these truths in our hearts, we do not constantly question the foundations; we grow in them (29–30).

Who, then, are the true progressives? Atwater answers that they are those who "believe, love, and obey, and do their utmost to lead others to believe, love, and obey the truth as it is in Jesus" (36). He leaves us with a memorable image: "The more rapid that train, the firmer must be the track" (36).

### Questions for Us

Christians cannot accept the culture's definition of progress. Neither can we assume that everything old must be preserved simply because it is old. We must confront sins and correct errors. But it is Scripture, not the spirit of the age, that must determine what needs reform and what must remain fixed. Otherwise, in our eagerness to correct one evil, we may uproot something God has declared good.

We should be suspicious whenever the church is told it must change to remain relevant. The church must never "progress" beyond the gospel or beyond the old paths of biblical fidelity.

So let me ask you: Have you confused what is new with what is good and true? Are you actually progressing in a biblical way? Are you becoming more holy, more faithful, more like Christ, more zealous for the spread of the gospel, or are you simply changing?

Let us hold fast to what is good, seek the old paths, and always abound in the work of the Lord.

Page numbers refer to Lyman H. Atwater, "The True Progress of Society," *Princeton Review*, January 1852.

